CH404625 - Charging penalties: interaction between penalties: details and examples: misuse of rebated oils penalties exceed 100% of the liability to tax

This page and chapter are under review as the relevant content is also published in the guidance chapters of the Compliance Handbook, within Compliance checks factsheets and in Compliance checks guidance. If you use particular pages regularly, please email hmrcmanualsteam@hmrc.gov.uk to let us know the specific content you find useful.

More than one penalty can be charged on an amount of Potential Lost Revenue (PLR) in respect of both the supply and use of a product that attracts a higher duty. For example, when

  • a product is used that attracts a higher rate of duty and
  • the supplier knew that it would be misused

both are liable to a penalty.

If the sum of the two penalties exceeds 100% you must reduce each penalty proportionately, as shown in the example below.

Guidance on making adjustments to penalties in the NPPS is at CH407720.

Example

Jim is a farmer and uses red diesel to run his tractors and other farm plant and machinery. Jim sells some of his red diesel to his friend George who runs a removals business, despite knowing that George uses it in his lorries.

George is liable to a penalty for using a product for a purpose that attracts a higher rate of duty, see CH91400. It is established that George’s behaviour is deliberate with a prompted disclosure and you determine a penalty of 45% of the PLR.

Jim is liable to a penalty for supplying the oil knowing that it will be used for a purpose that attracts a higher rate of duty. The penalty for this wrongdoing is 100%, subject to any reduction for disclosure. As Jim made a prompted disclosure you determine a penalty for this wrongdoing of 70% of the PLR.

The PLR is the same for both Jim and George.

Therefore, the total penalty is 115% (45% plus 70%).

As the total of the penalties charged cannot be more than the PLR, each penalty must be reduced, see below.

Name Calculation Percentage

George

45/115 x 100 =

39%

Jim

70/115 x 100 =

61%

If the penalties determined were 35% for George and 60% for Jim, as the total penalty does not exceed 100% of the PLR, no reduction would be necessary.